Tags
Experiment, gratitude, Intention, Life, Love, Mindful, Plants, Project 365, Seeds, Speech, Words
Not long ago, I read a story about a distant island where villagers would gather around wooded areas and utter curses until the trees fell one by one. The land, thus cleared, would be used for their settlements.
Can this be possible? Can your words be wielded as swords? What else could your words do?
My children and I set out to test this theory. Our scientific question was this:
Is it possible to alter the rate of growth of plants by exposing / speaking “good” and “bad” words to them?
On January 2nd, 2012 we setup our experiment as follows:
- We took three clear plastic cups and wrote a set of words on each cup.
1) “Love” and “Thankyou”
2)”Stupid” and “Idiot”
3)Control with no words(please click on picture for a full view)
- Wet paper towels were placed in each cup.We took three identical red beans and placed one in each cup.
- All cups were watered equally and placed in a cardboard box in a cupboard that got natural light.
- Every day the two children would “talk” to the cup once at 4:00PM. They said the words that written on the respective cup. No more, no less. They did not spend any time with the cup that was our control (with no words).
- As expected, the seeds started sprouting around the 10th day: January 11th, 2012
- The pictures below will show you the results of our experiment. The dates on the pictures are in dd/mm/yyyy format. (11/1/2012 is Jaunary 11th, 2012)
- Look at the growth in one day. On January 12th, 2012. Clearly, our “Love” seed is standing twice as tall.
.
There doesn’t seem to be much of a difference in growth between our “Control” and our “Stupid” seed, but that changes in two days.
- On January 14, 2012, the “Control” seed is showing steady growth, while our “Love” seed is outstanding. Our “Stupid” seed has shown no progress at all.

January 14, 2012. Comparing our 3 seeds. We found that we had accidently dropped two seeds in the control. One was removed.
- On January 26th, 2012, my children were very upset that the “Stupid” seed had started to look dry and sad (remember, we were watering them exactly the same same way, about 5ml of water every other day) and so they decided that they would not “talk” to the plants any more.
-(Please click on the picture to view it in full size.)
♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣♣
Over the next few days, I took my plants everywhere I went. I asked almost everyone I met what they thought about the experiment. Here are some of the responses.
School Nurse: “That just gave me the goose bumps.”
Kindergartener: “I think plants have feelings.”
School Principal: “This is fantastic. I must tell all the teachers about this. Would you like to come to a meeting and explain this?”
Second grade teacher: “I just have got to do this in my class.”
Chiropracter: “Oh my goodness. We know this anecdotally, but to actually see this – it goes to show how we can influence things around us.”
Registered Nurse/Dietician: “We’ve got to understand this. It gives me the goose bumps.”
5th grader: “Words have vibrations. Bad words can be mean.”
Acupuncturist: “This is so true. I think I am going to write this on one of my client’s foot!”
Masaru Emoto, in his book “Hidden Messages in Water“, writes: “Words are expression of our soul. And the condition of our soul is likely to have an enormous impact on the water that composes over 70% of our body, and this impact in no small way will affect our bodies.”
If this is all true, then is it possible to heal and nuture our sick seedling back to health? To complete our experiment, my children decided to use the words “I am sorry” and “You are cool!” In this experiment we will not “talk” to the plant, instead we will simply think thoughts directed at the plant. In other words, we will use our Intention.
In the next post, we will bring you the results of our experiment.
In the meantime, do tell us what you think.
Have you ever tried an experiment like this? What did you learn?
Would you like to try this experiment and post pictures? My children and I would love to hear from you.
It is a truly scientific phenomenon that when you change the way you look at things, the things you look at change. ~ Wayne Dyer







Amazing. Just amazing.
How lucky are your children! It needs a thinking and feeling adult to show a child the value of goodness. You’ve done it so well. But I must compliment your children as well for carrying on the tradition of a wholehearted mind.
The experiment is so complete in itself that it is difficult to say anything much except “Wow”. I have always had full faith in the power of kind speech. And I admit I feel kind intentions somehow make up for any lack of speech. I await the results of your next experiment! I am sure they’re going to be equally goosebumpy.
P.S. Can’t help sharing this with friends!
Priya, you are so kind. Thanks for sharing my post.
Wonder what it would do to all us humans- perhaps cease the rat race.!
What a wonderful life lesson for you to share with your children and then share the lesson with us. I’m not surprised by the results – just further encouraged to choose my words kindly.
Thank you so much. I strive to do the same. Will visit your blogworld in just a bit.
My friend Priya turned me onto this post, and I am so glad she did. It’s amazing, and I so admire your dedication as a parent. What clear and telling results. And I’m so impressed that you took this a step further and took your experiment around to show other people.
I will 100% be trying this with my children. That said, I do have some worries that we won’t duplicate your results. I’m not questioning what you did — it just seems too good for me to be able to get it to happen too. And I’d wonder what my kids would think if we called a plant “stupid” and then it grew the biggest.
I’m saying all this so you know, up front, that I am openly waiting to be surprised. Hoping. And because, deep down, I believe this will work. I’m an optimist, and I appreciate your “whole hearted” approach to this project. You are to be commended.
I understand your fear. A fellow commentator (read below) said that the test failed because one of the testers kept thinking “oh poor thing” and couldn’t do the test. Isn’t that is really interesting? In order to do this experiment, you will have to keep the environment fairly clear – you can’t “think” one thing and say something else.. My kids thought of it as a game, they played without expectations. What if you just did this with “Love” and “Control”, would that help you to feel differently about it? Maybe you’d like to read the book “Hidden MEssages in Water” first. Your library should have a copy. In this book, there are lots of pictures of water crystals (frozen). These crystals were made after water was “exposed” to good and bad words (even music). The pictures speak for themselves. In one experiment, the words “Let’s Do it” and “Do it” were tested. The “Do it!” which was meant to be a command resulted in a bad crytsal formation.
Here;s a video of this work.
This was a great experiment, and really fun. I love it!!!! I might even send it to my spiritual leader Ajahn Brahm in Australia, I think he would like it.
Thanks for sharing.
Maggie
Wow! Ajahn Brahm is my spiritual teacher, Nithya Shanthi’s teacher. I have read some of his works. I’ll be honored if you share this with him. I have so much to learn from my own experiment. My main lesson here was to stay “consistent” with my thoughts. I often go back and forth. Shout at my kids one moment and then hug them the next moment. How can I stay on the mindful path – stay in the present? – that is my quest. The quest simply translates to practise. Thank you so much for writing. May I ask how you found me? I am glad to have found you too.
The WholeHearted Mind,
Im not surprised at all that your a disciple of Ajahn. I could almost feel that kind of vibration in your post. Today Im living in Sweden, but I spent 4 years in Australia, Perth, and I have met Ajahn in person. I did 2,5 weeks of meditation in his monastery, and I have listed for his talks live. He is great!
I found you blog when searching for blogs tagged “Project 365″. I try to find new interesting stuff each day. Im also doing the project.
You can also send this post to Ajahn if you want, you find his address at the internet.
Maggie
Dear Aparna,
I love, LOVE, LOVE your experiment! I’ve already heard about tests like this. The plants, however, reacted differently. When the supervisor asked their assistants about how the experiment had been done, step by step, one of them replied, shyly: “I’m sorry, doctor, but when I would see the ‘stupid’ plant, I couldn’t avoid to think to myself: ‘poor little creature!’ Maybe my compassion has damaged the test…”
It confirms: we have to be careful about our words and our thoughts; and the best lesson is: lovely words, peaceful thoughts are powerful, indeed!
Thank you for sharing!
How wonderful – “Compassion spoiled the test!!” I think that’s why I asked my children to do it. I was not sure what would happen. I was very curious. The key to doing the experiment is to stay curious and not get to involved. Treat it just as an experiment.
The WholeHearted Mind,
Could you please address people with their name,, when answering? It makes it much easier to know to whom you are responding. Thank
Maggie
Maggie, Thank you for the suggestion. I will keep that in mind. That is surely a better way to reply.
It’s fantastic that you took the time to take your children through this experiment. It will be life transforming – evolutionary – for them.
And they get to pass it on!
Words my mother would not allow us to use as we grew up:
No Should, Must, or Have to. (Just do it…these words are fence sitters.)
No “B” words as expletives
No one was to be called “Stupid” (Or other names, but especially not this one.)
No negative put-downs of self.
My mother knew the power of words and self-talk. We learned to observe ourselves so we could occasionally catch ourselves in negative thinking. If we inadvertently spoke negatively, someone in the family would point it out!
The power of words is one of the reasons for The Virtues Project. It transforms thinking from criticism to praise.
Love this post. Thank you!
Amy, SoulDipper, Wow! what a beautiful story. I hope that I will stay consistent in my message to my children. I am constantly see-sawing between shouting and hugging. I must learn to stay in the moment without fear of the past or future. That was the biggest lesson I learnt from this experiment. I stopped at your blogsite. I am really looking forward to connecting with you. We have much in common. I am reading / practicing the lessons in the book, “The Intiuitve Way.” Have you read it?
Wonderful Aparna. I have the book which talks about what you just did..by Dr.Masaru…I guess it is high time i took to reading the book…
I am ashamed that as a mother of two, I have not begun setting myself into this mould …I am glad I could learn from your attempt.
I am happy that I am on Switchwords, which has given me a chance to look into myself more than what i look out…
Love to your children for experience such a wonderful moment with their thoughtful mother…who guides them thru the process of life..
I pray and wish to be a mother who is able to give more and more and more love my kids, so that they blossom to their best!
Regards
Archana
Aparna – I love that you did this experiment with your children and then hosted a web site and shared with the school and others. You are proactive and the world has become better for your actions. Thank you, thank you, thank you!!
Patricia
I read this post yesterday and went away speechless, feeling it was nothing short of a miracle. Today, I saw an email from Priya pointing me this way again. I am glad because today I have my wits about me, to say a bit of what I felt.
I am sure all of us have become aware at some stage of our lives, of the power of words/ speech. But to see it in such a simple way, is heartening. It moves me so!
Thank you so much for sharing this with us, Aparna.
( If there was a ‘love’ button for this one, I would click it
)
AIT, you are too sweet. Thanks for liking it.. that will do;-)) I have done several experiments on Intention. YOu might like some of these ideas. I often “plant” my wishes or intentions in the elements of nature – air, water, fire, eat.. that is, simply say the intention once or a few times, say as I plant new flowers, vegetables. So, something like “may my son do well in his tests/exams” or “may I become better at ”
“May xyz’s health/relationship become better.” I simply plant it without any expectation of how or when things will change. I simply remain curious. The results are always interesting, generally better than what I would have imagined. Try this … choose your favorite element. Drop a pebble in the ocean. much love.
I like this idea – it’s a way of “grounding” your intention and as you say, let it go remaining curious. Great experiment.
Patricia
HEnce I always try not to listen to songs that have negative lyrics I make it a point to listen to songs that give hope that promise optimism..
…but why would seeds understand the English language?
Ronnie
Roonie, so good to hear from you. I am still laughing over your TV program post.
Yours is an excellent question. It is not the “words” that matter, it is our emotions and our thoughts, the meaning we attach to these. Quantum Physicists are looking into this phenomena.. and interestingly, this is the topic of my next post..
I am so astounded by this experiment and even more by the responses you have received. Reading the affirmations to you gave me goosebumps. You are loved.
Susan, Thank you so much for stopping by and writing such a kind note. I am glad you liked the experiment. I hope you have loads of kindness come your way. May I ask, how you found this site?
It was posted on Facebook by a friend’s daughter.
Wow, this is so interesting! I may have to try this with my kids. I say over and over everyday “use a kind voice and kind words.” I think something concrete like this would be so fun and amazing for them to see.
Thanks, Christy! Do let me know if you try the experiment and what comes of it.
It proves beyond any two opinion that good words and thoughts can change the world. Tanks for sharing such a wonderful experiment with us.
I reblogged you on my wordpress site. Love the tangible visible evidence of our words, thoughts, intentions!
I also struggled when my kids were younger (and of course now-my son is 13 1/2 and my daughter is 9 1/2, but it’s different now for some reason). I felt like I was failing every single day when they were little trying to be the perfect spiritual mom. I knew what to do so why couldn’t I do it. But through practice and mindfulness, I started catching myself sooner and sooner when I started to get frustrated before the yelling and apologizing when necessary if I yelled or rather when I yelled Lol. In the last six years I’ve used chanting so when I am low on patience, I’ll silently chant a mantra to myself and if my kids are really driving me nuts I’ll say chant out loud which they looove (just kidding–they don’t love it but it does change the dynamic and makes it a little funnier and lightens the energy:)
AIT pointed me to this blog. The results of your experiment are totally amazing! I always knew that words are very powerful. Yet somehow I never imagined it would work like this in connection with plants. I am very impressed! You do wonderful work. Thank you so much for sharing.
Goes to show that tapping on positive energy and spreading it can make the world a better place. I work with plants every day and used to think myself odd when I caught myself talking to them at times. I guess I should be doing it more often. I am sharing this with more people especially mothers of little kids. Thank you for a lovely experiment.
What an awesome post.. we’ve all heard of the power of words but to see it being proven physically.. dazzling! one of my friends An idealist thinker.. recommended this post to me after reading something i had written on “words”.. am posting you a link.. check it out if you find the time.. http://justanotherwakeupcall.wordpress.com/2012/01/26/shshhhhhhh-the-words-are-asleep/
i will be sharing your post with my friends, if thats ok..
Pingback: SOMETIMES I FEEL LIKE A PARTICLE, SOMETIMES A WAVE | belas bright ideas
So happy to be connected with you! As you know, I wrote about this experiment, not knowing the origin of its source, on my own blogsite – I thought it that profound. Now I see you are connected to Priya (!) and a couple of others I ‘know.’ Six degrees of separation!
I believe that it the “sound” and not the “language” that is playing a role here.
It will be interesting to experiment with the tones reversed for “stupid” and “I love you”. Eg: saying “stupid” in a polite manner and “I love you” in a rude manner.
Hi Ashish, Thanks for your comment. Yes, it is entirely possible that the tone may matter in an experiment like this. I have just posted a response to some of these questions that came from readers and friends. Take a look at this new post and let me know what you think. http://wp.me/p1ZZWh-7q
This is truly incredible. I am so happy to have come here!
Thank you, Shakti. The honor is mine. I briefly stopped by at your site. There was loads to read. I will be back for more. I see we have very similar interests and background (perhaps?). I like this phrase you write “as I seek inner peace through Gratitude, Learning and Beauty.”
Pingback: Mindful Speech: Reflections from the Word Power Experiment « The WholeHearted Mind.
Reblogged this on lastmomstanding.com and commented:
What an amazing, authentic way to remind ourselves, and teach our children that our words and thoughts are one of the most powerful gifts we have.
I was excited to reblog your post and share it with everyone I am connected to. What a brilliant reminder that our words (and thoughts) are powerful energy! How amazing is it to be a human being; such unlimited potential.
I am looking forward to reading more of your posts.
Best!
Kimberly Crawford
Laugh hard. Love strong. Live to serve.
http://www.lastmomstanding.com
Kimberly: That is such an honor. I do not have enough thankyous to show my gratitude. I am so glad that you appreciate the power of words, of thoughts, and of kindness. Thanks!
Incredible post. I got link to this post from An Idealistic Thinker ( Although I do not like to mention her with this name, but I do not have any other way
). Now I realized, why did she give me link to this post? “. What a great job you people did at your home with this concept. This post gave me goose bumps.
Although I was aware of this island’s story, after watching a movie called, “Taare Zameen Par” long time back. But I was not sure if it’s completely true or not. After reading this post of yours, and seeing these proofs in form of photographs, I also started believing, “Yes Miracles can happen”. Thank you for such a wonderful post. Best wishes to you and your family.
Arindam,
Thank you for stopping by and to AIT as well for sending you over. I see you are blogger with many, many friends and awards – your words have brought you so many wonderful things. Keep up the good work, my friend. I hope to see lots of your work in the near future. I love the movie T-Z-P!! It shows that you can change your world with your words, thoughts and actions. Since you are an engineer, I wonder if you liked my “quantum physics” explanation of the power of our thoughts. http://wp.me/p1ZZWh-7q – Take your time… it’s long, you don’t have to read it.;-)
~Aparna
I just can’t seem to keep up with all the blogs I want to read, so I’m coming late to your party. What an interesting post, and what a fun idea to do the experiment with your children. I’m so intrigued I have to do it…
P.S. I only managed to photograph my food one day in January. Did you keep it up the whole month?
Great Experiment , thanks for sharing .
I agree with the tenor of the experiment & the line of conclusion …..EXCEPT , that , I feel it’s the power of THOUGHTS & not words . Words as in alphabets are just phonetic sounds — code sign only for those who understand .
Where it ‘ reaches ‘ is that , words act as a ‘ carrier ‘ / vehicle which carry our thoughts & emotions ….. which are what does the job
I’m sure your children when uttered those words , it came form their heart … touching their soul & sincerity & hence carried the emotions / thoughts behind ; which has the transforming power .
Next time , you may try another element in the experiment of using both the set of words , saying ‘ plainly ‘ without attaching any tonal or emotional variation between ‘ Love ‘ & ‘ Stupid ‘
Thanks .
Thank you, Yatin for your comment. Yes, the thoughts and feelings made this possible. Here is an explanation that follows http://wp.me/p1ZZWh-7q
As a child of people who did not understand the power of their words, what advice would you have for “undoing” the damage done of a childhood full of negative words?
Hi Grace,
I am not sure if I can offer advice. But since you ask, perhaps you can begin by forgiving your parents. You may or may not know their story – where they also victims of poor speech? You can strive to stick with positive speech and thoughts yourself – so you spread the right message to those around you. Sometimes things happen to us so we can learn from them. They do not happen “to” us but “for” us. Can you ask yourself, “what is the lesson in this?” “how can I love myself more?” There are also fantastic techniques out there that help us collapse the trauma of the past. If you’d like to know more, write back and I can email you some information.